Individual sticky toffee puddings with vanilla bean ice cream

31 Comments on Individual sticky toffee puddings with vanilla bean ice cream

Sticky toffee pudding with vanilla bean ice cream

In 1990, the world was a very different place. Nelson Mandela had just been released from prison, Margaret Thatcher was still in power, and the Hubble Space telescope was launched into orbit. This was the dawn of the information age, with the world wide web just a year away and science set to change beyond recognition (though it’s fair to say both technology and taste still had a fair way to go). Despite some major world-changing events taking place at the time, media of more immediate concern to my six-year-old self were such pressing issues as which magazine to buy (Horse & Pony, of course), what was on at the cinema (Home Alone), what to listen to on the radio (Madonna’s Vogue) and what to fight with my older brother over to watch on TV.

Amongst the various cartoons, BBC dramas and other viewing termed suitable by our parents, Delia Smith was a firm family favourite. This was an era post Fanny Cradock, yet nearly a decade before the likes of Jamie and Nigella first appeared on our screens, launching a whole new wave of kitchen enthusiasts and the start of our current obsession with cookery programmes. While Nigella flirts and slurps and Jamie rips and rummages his way through a kitchen strewn with fabulous foods from around the world, Delia portioned everything into perfect little pre-prepared white bowls, carefully instructing us step-by-step and introducing the early 90s viewer to such exotic ingredients as anchovies (pronounced with a Loyd Grossman-esque long ‘o’ which always made us giggle).


Syrupy sticky toffee pudding, ready for a second bake

While Delia may not have the casual confidence or slinky seduction techniques of a Jamie or a Nigella, she always made a jolly good British meal, and I still remember the excitement of watching her make sticky toffee puddings in an episode of Delia Smith’s Christmas all those years ago. Sticky toffee pudding is the ultimate winter warmer, a British classic of unconfirmed origin – some say it was invented at Sharrow Bay Country House Hotel in the 70s, while others claim a much more ancient heritage – and the kind of comfort food that puts warmth in your belly and a smile on your face.

Delia’s version sees eight individual puddings baked in the oven before being drenched in a thick, sticky sauce and returned to the grill for a further five minutes to crisp and caramelize. I’ve never much liked traditional Christmas pudding, and watching these sweet little sponges emerge from the oven, I imagined that when I was older these would be the dessert that would feature on my Christmas menu (along with chocolate coins, chocolate oranges and very few Brussels sprouts. . .).


Squidgy cake, buttery sauce & melting ice cream

It’s not quite Christmas yet, but winter is starting to make itself known. Last week we put the heating on for the first time this year, and I feel like the time has come to replace ice creams and sorbets with something altogether more comforting and hearty. Sticky toffee pudding should never be stodgy or dense, but it provides a sweet satisfaction on a cold winter’s day that only a syrupy sponge smothered in lashings of thick, hot sauce can.

The version below takes some tips from Delia, but has been tweaked to my personal taste. I like plenty of thick sauce and a pudding with a crispy top but fluffy middle, so have replaced the grilling method with a minute or two more baking, and preferring a smoother pudding have omitted the addition of nuts. Flavour and texture can be tweaked as you see fit – great add-ins include a handful of pecans or walnuts, a splash of rum or whisky and a pinch of ground or crystallized ginger, although I’m not sure this latter addition doesn’t turn it into a ginger pudding and a slightly different proposition altogether.


The sweetest, stickiest mouthful of a pretty much perfect pudding

However you make your puddings, be sure to serve them hot, with a little jug of extra sauce for the ultimate indulgence and lashings of ice cream or thick pouring cream to cut through the buttery sweetness of this great British classic. Enjoy.

Individual sticky toffee puddings (devised by way of Delia Smith, Delicious magazine & Felicity Cloake)
(makes 4)

For the puddings


112g soft medjool dates, pitted and roughly chopped
100ml water boiling water (can be substituted with 50ml alcohol if you’re feeling especially festive)
1/2 tsp bicarbonate of soda
100g plain flour
1/2 tsp baking powder
Pinch salt
40g butter, softened
60g soft light brown sugar
1 large free range egg, beaten
2tsp golden syrup
1/2 tsp vanilla extract


Preheat the oven to 175 degrees C. Grease 4 individual pudding moulds with butter.

Put the dates, water and rum into a small pan and bring to the boil over a medium heat, then simmer for about 5 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the dates are very soft. Stir in the bicarbonate of soda and set aside to cool.

Meanwhile, sift the flour, baking powder and a pinch of salt into a bowl. In another bowl, cream the softened butter and the sugar together with an electric hand whisk until light and fluffy. Add the egg, golden syrup and vanilla extract and whisk again to incorporate.

Fold half the flour mixture into the creamed eggs, butter and sugar, followed by half the dates. Do the same with the remaining halves until all ingredients are fully incorporated. Divide equally between your four moulds, set on a tray (this will save your oven in the unlikely event that they spill over the top) and bake for 15-18 minutes, until the top is golden, a skewer comes out clean and the middle is just ever so slightly squidgy.

For the sauce


80g butter
80g dark brown muscovado sugar
150ml double cream


Melt the butter, sugar and double cream in a small pan. Bring to the boil then simmer for three minutes until smooth and thickened.

To assemble the puddings

Make a small slit in the top of each pudding and pour in about a teaspoon of sauce. Drizzle a little more over the top and return to the oven for a couple more minutes until golden and bubbling.

Remove the puddings from their moulds, slather on another coat of sauce and serve with a dollop of cool creamy ice cream or a little jug of cream. Yum.

31 RESPONSES TO Individual sticky toffee puddings with vanilla bean ice cream

  1. This would be just what I need on a monday morning! Wish I was at home so I could make it and snug in the sofa with it 🙂

  2. Sticky toffee puddings are one of my all-time favourite puddings and I just know that a Delia recipe is going to be perfect.

    Also, you were a much cooler 6 year old than I was. In 1990, I was the biggest Jason Donovan fan.

  3. Jamie -

    What a great post! What fabulous writing! And ooooh if I haven’t yet made a sticky toffee pudding then I have just been inspired! Gorgeous and tempting! And who doesn’t prefer a single, personal portion? Fabulous!

  4. This look utterly gorgeous! And so perfect for this time of year to blast the chill away! Thank you for sharing x

  5. These do look a proper level of stickiness. I’ve only eaten sticky toffee pudding once, but I think I might have give it another go. I’m presuming I can indulge the clotted cream habit you’ve given me with this as well? YUM!

    • Regula – taking the day off work to eat sticky toffee pudding would be a pretty perfect way to spend a Monday 🙂

      Kathryn – I never said I wasn’t a Jason Donovan fan too… 🙂

      Jamie – aw, thank you. Individual portions are definitely the way forward – this is more than big enough to satisfy the sweetest solo tooth!

      Urvashi – my pleasure, so pleased you like the post.

      Miss South – they are suitably sticky without being too sickly. And yep, clotted cream would be a great accompaniment 🙂

  6. My friend made a sticky toffee pudding for our monthly Sunday roast catch up last weekend. It brought a smile to all our faces. Loved the part about Lloyd Grossman’s long “Os”. When I was 5 my ambition was to go on junior masterchef.. guess I missed the boat a bit. Oh well.

  7. As the weather begins to get steamy here in Syndey, I feel myself (almost) wishing it was cooling down so I could make this beautiful dish! I think this will be the first thing I make when winter comes next year!

  8. Sticky toffee pudding is my absolute favorite dessert! These look sooo delicious!

  9. Ahh yes Delia! I enjoy watching her too although she’s quite a different proposition from Jamie and Nigella as you say! 🙂

  10. This is, without a doubt, my all-time favourite pudding. Nothing beats it, apart from maybe treacle tart. I like that you’ve made both in the last month or so – clearly someone after my own heart!

    • Ruthie – I used to love watching Masterchef when I was little. John and Greg do a good job nowadays, but Loyd Grossman will always be the first person I think of when I hear the word ‘Masterchef’!

      Anna – very jealous of your summer time, although I guess at least the cold means I can indulge in desserts like this 🙂

      Carly – thanks!

      Lorraine – Delia feels pretty dated on TV now, but her recipe books contain some real classics.

      Elly – I reckon treacle tart and sticky toffee pudding have to be up there with the best British puddings ever. Great minds 🙂

  11. These look delicious! I love eating sticky toffee pudding after a roast dinner, but it must be served with pouring cream!

  12. I am drooling on my keyboard looking at these! I never used to like sticky toffee puddings but now I love them.

  13. I love Delia too, but come to think of it I’ve never actually tried one of her recipes. I love the look of these sticky toffee puddings though. You had me at the word sticky!!

  14. Amy -

    Yummy! I have ALWAYS wanted to make this! But funny this, I don’t think I’ve ever even tried it, haha. It just looks so good! Maybe I’ll have something of a british-featured-desser this christmas. 🙂

  15. I am sure this tasted superb.. pudding and ice cream would have to be on my to die for foods.

  16. yumMMY! I love vanilla bean ice cream and sticky toffee pudding. what a great combination isnt it? lovely!

    • Mandy – I think ice cream is my favourite accompaniment, but if offered pouring cream I wouldn’t say no!

      Baking Addict – glad you’ve been converted to the sticky toffee cause 🙂

      Jennifer – Delia writes some great classics, definitely worth giving her recipes a go. She’s my fall back if I want basic techniques which I can then develop in my own recipes.

      Amy – you definitely need to try this 🙂 Would be a great alternative to Christmas pudding too.

      Sherilyn – hot pudding and cold melting ice cream is a combination it’s hard to beat.

      Iva – sure is! 🙂

  17. Delia is still my “go to” resource if I want to read a recipe or technique. The newer, more tv friendly, chefs are ok but Delia remains the only one for me!

    Your STP looks fab. I could eat it right now even though it’s only 8.25am!

  18. Alana -

    you know you’re onto a good vanilla ice cream when you can see the flecks of vanilla bean! the pudding and ice cream is a wonderful pairing and they both look fantastic.

  19. I adore sticky toffee pudding. And a major thanks for posting this as I’ve been looking for a recipe after I ate one the other day in a restaurant and was totally disapointed! Which of course then sent me off an a quest to find a proper one! I’ve bookmarked the post 🙂

    • Sylvie – lots of sauce is an absolute must with this pudding!

      The Caked Crusader – nothing wrong with craving desserts for breakfast 🙂 And yes, where would we all be without Delia?!

      Alana – thank you 🙂

      Rayna – definitely give it a go, you won’t be disappointed.

      Clare – so pleased you found this post – do let me know how you get on with the recipe.

  20. Suzanne -

    Thank you so much for this recipe! Made it over Christmas and again today for a New Years Day lunch – much loved by all! Had it with home-made mixed spice ice-cream and everybody said it was all delicious! Which considering one person considers themselves a sticky toffee pudding officiando is saying something. Thanks again for a classic start to the New Year – hope you have a great 2012 full of culinary inspiration!

  21. Maxine -

    Do you think this can be made up to adding the sauce then left and put back into the over for a little longer just before you want to serve?

    I don’t really want to be cooking lots with guests round…..

    • Suzanne – ah, that’s my pleasure! So pleased you and your guests enjoyed it so much 🙂

      Maxine – definitely. Just bake them as per instructions up to putting in the sauce, then set to one side. You can also make the sauce in advance. Then, about 30 mins before you’re ready to serve, just heat up the oven and sauce, pour it over your puddings and pick up on the final stages. Hope that helps 🙂

      • Maxine -

        Excellent! This may have made it onto my 3 course meal list then!

  22. Decadence thy name is sticky date
    Thank you for introducing us 🙂

    Choc Chip Uru
    Latest: Maple Raisin Ice Cream

  23. Liz -

    They’ve just come out of the oven and I’m just about to bring them round to a friend’s house for the dessert course of a dinner party. Fingers crossed they taste as good as they smell and look! Will post tomorrow. Thanks for the recipe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.